The records concerning Johnne Gordoun, who was also known by the alias Johnne Gray-meill, place him within the turbulent context of early modern Haddington. His involvement in the judicial proceedings of the period is complex, as historians have noted that he may be the same individual as the figure referred to as "Jokkie Gray-meil." While the archival fragments acknowledge the difficulty in reconciling these two distinct names, both were identified in the trial of the notable accused witch Agnes Sampsoune, suggesting a peripheral but documented proximity to the high-profile supernatural inquiries that defined the era.
In May 1608, legal proceedings against Johnne culminated in a formal trial. The judicial process led to a verdict of guilty, and in accordance with the statutes and social expectations governing such charges at the time, he was sentenced to death. The records confirm that the sentence was carried out, marking the end of a life caught within the rigid, often fatal legal apparatus of seventeenth-century Scotland. His case remains a sober reflection of the documentation surviving from this era, illustrating the swift and final nature of the judicial system as applied to those swept up in the pursuit of witchcraft.