In the summer of 1671, the legal authorities in Roxburgh turned their attention to Andrew Laidlay, an individual who claimed origins in Liven. Andrew was formally charged in connection with attendance at a meeting of witches, a grave accusation that positioned him firmly within the judicial mechanisms of late seventeenth-century Scotland. The administrative response to his case was swift, as evidenced by an order issued on May 24, 1671, which mandated his transfer to the tolbooth of Edinburgh.
Despite the directive to relocate Andrew to the capital, historical records indicate that the transfer was never executed. Beyond the judicial paperwork, documentation confirms that he was subjected to an unspecified form of torture, a procedure frequently employed during this period to extract information or testimonies regarding clandestine gatherings. By July 3, 1671, the records associated with case C/EGD/589 remain a testament to the brief and localized legal entanglement that Andrew faced within the turbulent landscape of the Scottish witch trials.